Girls # 7-10
By The Luna Brothers
Published by Image Comics
I was feeling seduced by Girls. There it's been, a big, gorgeous box, just staring at me day upon day. Night upon night. I've got this humongous hardcover edition of the entire series. Putting it away would be a commitment to taking it back out when it's time to read it again - and that just feels like too much work. So, there it is, hanging out in the living room like a grandparents book of World War 2 photographs that no one ever looks at. Makes a great little desktop for my laptop, though!
I jumped into the Volume 2, finally. (The comic is split into four "Acts", I read the first one about a month ago. My intent was to read the whole second Act and report on the experience... but I couldn't make it, and I had to stop.
I'm not abandoning ship, not at all. But honestly, it the way the story is being told has gotten a little boring. It's a whole bunch of "that happens! Now this happens!" I can't expect everything to always be at a high note, and if it were, the high notes would get pretty boring. This is true in all relationships. Sometimes both parties are operating at low levels of energy. You know, you just hang out and enjoy each others company. But you need to hang out with "your friends" a little bit, to bring back some zing, otherwise you start attaching those moments of boredom to the other person, and home becomes a cell, and relationships become the sentence. Everything needs it's opposite in order to enjoy itself. I wouldn't full enjoy this vacation and time off if I didn't experience some stress, right? A great meal isn't so great if you come to it full - huh? I'm not trying to say Girls is bad, but maybe this style of reading is, because it's losing its ability to startle and surprise, its become toneless. The Sword made me hungry, it was something where my anticipation made it sweeter. But if I know what's coming, maybe not the substance, but at least the method, the experience--it dulls, just a bit.
I don't know what is to come, but perhaps the Luna brothers were still finding their way around the medium of comic books when they wrote this. Essentially, the first three issues of the 2nd act are what you might describe as treading water. Not that much happens that moves things along toward either a resolution of the conflict or a deeper conflict to be resolved. People talk around things, they expand on what's happened already, there's a lot of scenes where everyone says "Oh my god, did you see that?" In real life, that would make sense--you'd turn to someone to verify the insane, so as to not be insane yourself--but in a story, in fiction, in a visual medium like comics, it's pointless. I'm here, the reader, we're the one who witnesses what occurs, a verbal verification amongst the fictional characters is unnecessary.
And sure, the whole town is still trapped and bewildered. Things that "happen" are probably preparing to set the scene for a whole lot of drama. But at the moment, it's that part that all horror movies have. There's a calm before the storm. It's a pause, and it seems strapped on. It's a whole bunch of tension as everyone is hanging on wondering what's going to happen next. I don't need their wonder. I've got my own, there's is just an attachment, and its one I can't convince myself to buy into.
A bunch of "drama" does happen - but not that plays into what's going on with the Girls. Wes, the police dude, takes a handful of guys to try and find a way out. The run into the wall again. They see army dudes in hazmat suits on the other side and figure out that the army dudes can't see them - they can only see their own reflection. There's a sense of relaxation knowing that help might be on the way, but then the tension is back because we realize we have no idea when or how that may happen. (Which we already had before, its not like that feeling can be raised until the stakes--trapped in a dome--are as well. Meanwhile, the Scooby gang meets up with a snake and then a bear. So, like, OH MY GOD- BEAR ATTACK. But no, not really. Who cares? It has nothing to do with the story, it's just a tacked on thing that feels like a badly told joke.
Act two started with everyone on that two lane bridge that heads out of town - but they came to a halt because of "the wall". And suddenly the bridge starts to crack and crumple and people go sliding to their deaths. As everyone else goes to run off the bridge, the Girls come chasing them. They beat and pulverize one woman, and they get a guy. Everyone runs to the McAllister's. And hours later, the guy shows up, and it turns out he had sex with all four of them, even though he didn't really want to. (But he kind of wanted to and they totally wanted to, so that's how that worked out.
Long story long, everyone finds out about Ethan having sex with the original Girl, producing the eggs where the clones came from. And so now the danger is that there may be more eggs hatching as we speak. And yet, no one can focus on that for some reason. Everyone gets focused on Ethan and how it's all his fault.
It's almost like the Luna Brothers are fully aware that they are not getting to the point in the story, so they use a hilarious story line with Ethan and his ex-girlfiend Taylor. She's mad at him for having sex with that girl and says he cheated on her. Ethan, rightfully flabbergasted, exclaims that he did not cheat on her - that he and Taylor haven't spoken to each other in 6 months. For some stupid reason, though, she claims that this does not mean they were broken up. It's weird. But just as I'm thinking, WTF?, Ethan is like - WE ARE LOSING SIGHT OF THE ISSUE HERE! WE HAVE A PROBLEM TO SOLVE AND IT'S NOT OUR RELATIONSHIP!
Yes, exactly what i was thinking. But I was thinking it not because I buy that part of the story, but because I don't buy that part, because it feels like something that was crammed in there so that Ethan could freak out and remind the other characters what the main problem is, which is the Girls. It felt like a lot of work was being put in--pages of this stuff, dialog, drawings--just to get to the same thing that was the focus before this silly interlude about his relationship started.
I'm pretty sure that the shit is about to go DOWN. But I lost some momentum in this reading. I imagine if I were reading it at one issue per week (or month) it's be just fine. But three and a half issues, back-to-back of suspended tension got me bored. Thing is, if it WERE a movie, it'd be fine. This when you could safely go to the bathroom, get a popcorn refill or make-out with your date, knowing that although you'd miss some details, you'd really only be missing tension building up to the "big thing". In a movie situation - you're not alone. It's a shared experience. Even if you just turn to your friend and roll your eyes - you're still out getting your daily socialization. But in this case, it's just me. I've opted for a solitary commitment to reading, rather than hanging out with friends. There is no shared experience of tension here. It's just me and the story, on a date, and I was beginning to lose interest.
So, I stopped. For now. Took a little break. I'll get back to it. Perhaps later today. (Okay, i'm leaving town to go to the beach, so that's a lie.) Perhaps next week? The story still intrigues me, I want to know how it's going to turn out. This is not over. This is not a "break" like Ross & Rachel. It's just a pause. A pause to let my interest get invigorated again. Be back soon....
-Nina Stone, 2010
Recent Comments